Susan H. Butler

Partner


Blue and white plaque with the text: "Leading Lawyers. Susan Hickman Butler. Peer Selected 2024.
A badge displaying "Avvo Rating 10.0" in red, with "Susan Hickman Butler" and "Top Attorney" written in blue, framed by a shield outline with a blue ribbon.
Blue badge with the text "RATED BY Super Lawyers," followed by "Susan H. Butler" in white. At the bottom, on a gray background, is "SuperLawyers.com" in white.
Award badge titled "Avvo Clients' Choice Award 2018" with the name "Susan Hickman Butler." Below the text is a blue ribbon banner featuring five gold stars.
Graphic for the 2024 Official Community’s Choice Awards features a city skyline, stars, and bold text announcing Susan Butler as Best Divorce Attorney in Peoria.

“I am committed to maintaining integrity, preparing each case thoroughly, and treating my clients as I would want to be treated.”

Susan Butler is the Founding Partner of Butler, Giraudo & Meister, P.C., and has earned her reputation as a successful family law litigator and attorney over 40 years of practice in Central Illinois.

Susan has broad experience handling complex asset division, pension issues, and maintenance matters for both men and women. Clients seek her representation for challenging cases such as those involving professional practices, business interests, and farm properties. She has expertise in handling difficult employment, pension, and retirement issues, including dealing with stock options, executive compensation, Golden Parachute issues, and the drafting of qualified domestic relations orders and qualified orders for the division of federal and state pensions.

Susan is a versatile attorney who offers her clients a range of options for resolving their disputes. She is an experienced litigator who handles her cases with finesse in the courtroom, but she also has a record of settling even the toughest of cases by agreement between the parties.

Susan believes the client comes first and should be treated with respect. She is a natural advocate, learning what is important to her client, and then persuasively telling the client’s story to the court to achieve a successful result. Susan thrives on researching the law, analyzing the facts, and being fully prepared.

Susan also has extensive experience in preparing pre-and post-nuptial agreements, from both the side of the asset-advantaged and the disadvantaged, future spouse. She has a very successful record in the Third and Fourth District Illinois Appellate Courts, with numerous appellate affirmations.

Susan and her husband are blessed to have two children and five grandchildren who make life even more rich and exciting. Susan is a Stephen Minister and a lover of art, music, travel, philosophy and holidays.

Three office scenes: A woman at a desk, two women laughing together, and a document handover between colleagues. All are in a professional setting with books and art in the background.

Education

Susan (Hickman) Butler graduated magna cum laude from the University of Memphis in 1974, where she was inducted into the Mortar Board Society honoring excellence in scholarship, leadership and service. She received her Doctor of Jurisprudence from The Law School of Drake University in 1977. At Drake, she served as Editor of the Drake Legal Research Service and as Research Assistant to Associate Dean Arthur K. Ryman. She was admitted to the Iowa State Bar Association in 1977, and she practiced in Iowa until returning to her native Central Illinois where she was admitted to the Illinois State Bar Association in 1979. She is admitted to practice before the Illinois Supreme Court and the U.S. District Court for the Central District of Illinois.

Honors And Awards

  • Outstanding Achievement Award for Professions from the Pekin YWCA
  • Outstanding Professional Achievement Award, Pekin YWCA
  • Super Lawyer – 2005 to present
  • Woman of Achievement Award
  • Women in Management
  • Boss of the Year
  • Peoria Legal Secretaries Association

Memberships And Offices

  • Peoria and Peoria County Bar Associations
  • Illinois State Bar Association
  • Past President, Women in Management, Peoria Chapter

Read Our

Recent Blogs

How Can I Get My Spouse’s Visitation to Be Supervised in Illinois?

Navigating the complexities of co-parenting after a split, especially when safety concerns arise, can be challenging. For parents in Illinois who believe unsupervised visitation…

Read More
When Is It Time to Quit Negotiating & Let a Judge Decide in Illinois?

Many Illinois couples choose to resolve their divorce outside of court to bypass lengthy legal battles. This route necessitates both spouses reaching a joint…

Read More
Can I Get a Divorce in Illinois If My Spouse Is Living Abroad?

Divorce when a spouse lives internationally can appear daunting, yet geographical separation doesn't negate your right to end your marriage. Generally, Illinois courts can…

Read More

Contact Us Today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Group of attorneys